Court of Appeal rejects challenge to compensation award for employee death



Trial Result: The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal from a financial firm against an award of damages to the family of an employee of the firm who died in a helicopter crash. The court reaffirmed that the firm had breached the duty of care it owed its employee as regards the safety of the flight, and this had caused his death.

Analysis

The deceased employee, investment banker Tomas Dusek, was one of a dozen executives killed when a chartered helicopter got into difficulties at 16,000ft and crashed into a mountain in Peru in June 2012. The flight was to observe progress on a billion dollar hydro-power project.

His family sued his London-based employer, StormHarbour Securities LLP, saying it had failed in its duty to ensure the flight was safe.

In 2015 a judge ruled that StormHarbour was fully liable for Mr Dusek’s death in the ‘high risk’ flight over the Andes. He ruled that the accident was caused by the crew’s ‘disregard or lack of knowledge’ of the helicopter’s limitations and the difficult terrain, and that, although the flight was clearly dangerous in deteriorating weather conditions, the crew ‘failed to withstand client pressure’ to take off.

On 24 June 2016 at the Court of Appeal, StormHarbour’s lawyers argued the judge’s decision flew in the face of reason as Mr Dusek was a ‘high level employee with great autonomy’, who was not averse to taking risks, and was able to decide for himself whether to get on the flight.

StormHarbour argued it was ‘wholly unrealistic’, from its base in London, to carry out a risk assessment of events on the other side of the world.

However, Justice Baker ruled StormHarbour’s appeal ‘hopeless’. He said the flight across the mountains was ‘inherently dangerous’, and that however independent-minded he may have been, Mr Dusek would have obeyed an instruction from StormHarbour not to get on board.

He said the firm ‘knew or ought to have known’ of the risks involved, but ‘no inquiry was carried out at all’. StormHarbour had breached the duty of care it owed Mr Dusek as his employer and this had caused his death, he concluded.

The amount of compensation has yet to be assessed, but is expected to be a seven-figure sum.



LNB News 24/06/2016 82 and Lexis Nexis

 

Subscribe to Updates
Subscribe to:
Like   Back to Top   Seen 41 times   Liked 0 times

Subscribe to Updates

If you enjoyed this, why not subscribe to free email updates ?

Subscribe to Blog updates

Enter your email address to be notified of new posts:

Subscribe to:

Alternatively, you can subscribe via RSS

‹ Return to Blog

We never share or sell your email address to anyone.

I've already subscribed / don't show me this again

Recent Posts

Grantham firm fined after death of forklift truck driver

| 23rd September 2017 | Blogging

A Grantham company has been fined £300,000 at Lincoln Crown Court for a breach of health and safety regulations following the death of a forklift truck driver. Vacu-Lug Traction Tyres Ltd, based at Gonerby Hill Foot, had previously admitted a charge of failing to ensure the health and safety of its employees following the death of Stephen Woollas in July 2014. The company was also ordered to pay £25,000 towards prosecution costs. Mr Woollas, who was not wearing a seat belt, died after the forklift truck he was driving tipped over crushing him underneath it. Alex Stein, prosecuting, said that although the company had health and safety policies in place requiring workers to wear seat belts they did not enforce it. The investigation into the death of Mr Woollas revealed that the warning device on the seat belt which should have sounded if the belt was not being worn had been disabled. Instead the belt had been clipped into the latching mechanism behind the seat. Other forklift trucks at the premises, which remoulds tyres, also had the warning device disabled. The company also failed to enforce a policy that forklift driver should only use reverse when their view going forwards was obstructed. At the time of the fatal incident Mr Woollas was moving a load of tyres while travelling forward but was unable to fully see what was ahead of him. Mr Stein said: “Mr Woollas was driving a fork-lift truck at the company’s site when the truck tipped onto its side and he was crushed under it. “He was driving without a seat belt carrying a load of tyres. There was a restricted view available to him as he was driving forwards. The requirement to reverse in the fork-lift truck wasn’t being enforced. “The forklift truck became destabilised and tipped over. The investigator is confident that the destabilising came from riding over a tyre. Because Mr Woollas was driving forward with a stack in front of him he had no chance of seeing anything. “As the fork-lift truck fell over Mr Woollas was trapped. Workers did their very best to free him and an ambulance was called but tragically he did not survive.” Mr Woollas’ daughter Emily, in a statement read to the court, said: “So many of us have so many beautiful memories of my dad. His sudden and tragic death has left a huge void in all our lives.” Malcolm Galloway, for Vacu-Lug, said “The company accepts by its plea that it did not do sufficient. “This is not a bad company. It had taken health and safety very, very seriously and was doing its utmost to make sure that its employees worked within a safe environment. “This was a company with systems in place to try and be proactive with health and safety. This is not a case of total failure by the company due to disregard and not caring.” He said the firm, which has a current turnover of £17 million, has a deficit in its pension fund. “This is a company that is in a genuinely difficult financial position most of which is not the responsibility of the current management.” Source Lincolnshire Reporter...

Lincolnshire firm fined after worker fell 7m from forklift truck

| 04th September 2017 | Personal Injury

A worker suffered serious injuries when he fell while carrying out maintenance work at a Lincolnshire seafood processing factory, a jury was told. Virginius Kurselis was standing inside a box held up by a forklift truck when he fell seven metres while painting at the Fishgate Ltd factory at Brookenby near Market Rasen. Mr Kurselis spent four weeks on hospital and underwent two operations as a result of injuries he received as a result of the fall in July 2013. His left leg was shattered and his right foot was broken. He also suffered a cracked pelvis and a dislocated right arm. Robert Stevenson, prosecuting, said that Mr Kurselis was employed as a packer but was asked to paint gutterings and down pipes in preparation for a visit from a customer. Mr Kurselis initially used a ladder but changed and stood in a box which was lifted by a forklift truck to the required height. Mr Stevenson said: “Unfortunately the box tipped forward and Mr Kurselis fell. “Mr Kurselis was employed as a factory operative. His role was as a packer but on the day he was asked to do some painting. “The company was expecting a visit from a new customer and wanted the building to look more presentable. “He wasn’t given any training as to how to safely carry out that work. “There was an absence of any instruction and there was an absence of any supervision.” Fishgate Ltd of Brookenby Business Park, Binbrook, denied a charge of failing to discharge a duty of health, safety and welfare of an employee. The firm was convicted by a jury following a short trial and fined £100,000 and ordered to pay £19,032 prosecution costs The company is currently in administration and was not represented in court. Recorder Paul Mann QC, passing sentence, said: “Mr Kursilis was given no advice as to how to do this safely and no equipment apart from a tin of paint and a brush. “This was an accident waiting to happen. “He was very badly injured. He could so easily have been killed.”   Lincolnshire Reporter...

Five people hospitalised after serious road accident on the A18.

| 26th August 2017 | Personal Injury

  Five people, including two children, have been taken to hospital following a crash on the A18.   The incident happened at around 5.15pm on Wednesday, July 26 after a two vehicle crash was reported close to Hall Farm in Melton Ross Barnetby, near Humberside Airport.   A grey Nissan Navara and a silver coloured Audi estate car collided and a road closure was required to enable the attendance of emergency services.   The injuries to the children are thought to be minor, however one person is believed to have sustained serious injuries.   A man believed to be the driver of the Nissan left the scene of the collision and enquiries were undertaken to locate him without success.   Those enquiries are ongoing.   The road re-opened at 10.30pm.   Anyone with information is asked to call Humberside Police on 101 quoting log 397 of July 26.   Humberside Police originally said that the Audi driver fled the scene of the crash. However, they have now said that they believe the Nissan driver left the scene.   Source – Lincolnshire Reporter...

Lincolnshire firm fined after worker fell 7m from forklift truck

| 03rd August 2017 | Personal Injury

Lincolnshire firm fined after worker fell 7m from forklift truck A worker suffered serious injuries when he fell while carrying out maintenance work at a Lincolnshire seafood processing factory, a jury was told. Virginius Kurselis was standing inside a box held up by a forklift truck when he fell seven metres while painting at the Fishgate Ltd factory at Brookenby near Market Rasen. Mr Kurselis spent four weeks on hospital and underwent two operations as a result of injuries he received as a result of the fall in July 2013. His left leg was shattered and his right foot was broken. He also suffered a cracked pelvis and a dislocated right arm. Robert Stevenson, prosecuting, said that Mr Kurselis was employed as a packer but was asked to paint gutterings and down pipes in preparation for a visit from a customer. Mr Kurselis initially used a ladder but changed and stood in a box which was lifted by a forklift truck to the required height. Mr Stevenson said: “Unfortunately the box tipped forward and Mr Kurselis fell. “Mr Kurselis was employed as a factory operative. His role was as a packer but on the day he was asked to do some painting. “The company was expecting a visit from a new customer and wanted the building to look more presentable. “He wasn’t given any training as to how to safely carry out that work. “There was an absence of any instruction and there was an absence of any supervision.” Fishgate Ltd of Brookenby Business Park, Binbrook, denied a charge of failing to discharge a duty of health, safety and welfare of an employee. The firm was convicted by a jury following a short trial and fined £100,000 and ordered to pay £19,032 prosecution costs The company is currently in administration and was not represented in court. Recorder Paul Mann QC, passing sentence, said: “Mr Kursilis was given no advice as to how to do this safely and no equipment apart from a tin of paint and a brush. “This was an accident waiting to happen. “He was very badly injured. He could so easily have been killed.”   Lincolnshire Reporter...